YOUNG, BLACK AND IN DANGER
MEN IN PRISON, ON DRUGS, IN THE STREETS AND
IN THE MORGUE: THE NUMBERS ARE ALARMING.
Jul 15, 1990
By Thomas Ferrick Jr. and Jerry W. Byrd , Inquirer Staff Writers
In relentlessly increasing numbers, this generation of the city's poor,
young black men is ending up on drugs, in shelters, in jail or in the morgue.
They show up so often and in such great numbers in the statistics on
crime and drug abuse, homelessness and homicide that alarm is spreading among
those who work with the poor.
Some public officials are using drastic language to describe the
situation.
Louis W. Sullivan, the head of the U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services, calls black males a "species in danger. "
Bilal Qayyum, a gang worker turned city housing official, fears "we
are witnessing self-genocide taking place. "
Today in Philadelphia there are almost 101,000 black males between 15 and
34, the age range most frequently used to define young people in statistics
kept by the U.S. Census Bureau and others. These men represent a small slice of
the city's population: 6 percent.
Yet they show up in vastly larger proportions in statistics on drug
abuse, crime, homelessness and homicide - data that, taken together, could be
called the "Distress Index. "
Poor black men have always been a large part of these statistics. But
never in numbers like these:
One out of five of all young, black men in the city is under the
supervision of the criminal justice system. They have been convicted of crimes
and are serving time in jail, on probation or parole, or in juvenile detention.
Seventy-five percent of those on probation or parole for robbery in the
city, and nearly 80 percent of those in juvenile detention, are young black
men.
Only one out of every 16 Philadelphians is a young black man. But that
group accounts for one out of every five adults in homeless shelters. And two
out of every five city residents enrolled in city-run drug-treatment programs.
Then there are those who end up dead. In the nation and in Philadelphia,
homicide is the No. 1 cause of death among young black men.
More than 1,500 black men aged 15 to 34 have been killed in this city in
the last 11 years, a rate five times higher than that of their white male
counterparts, 19 times higher than the statewide average. In Philadelphia,
these men are slain at a rate higher than the already high national average for
young black men.
"Black people always killed each other. . . . The difference today
is the rate we're killing each other," said Qayyum, who became so
concerned about the increase in killings that he recently organized a group to
combat black homicide.
Almost 26 years ago, President Lyndon B. Johnson signed what has become a
landmark in American history: the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Take that year as a
beginning point, measure the progress made by American blacks since then, and
it becomes clear that strides have been made - economically, politically, on
almost every important scale.
Yet, many black children born in those years of promise have ended with
histories like the one told by Randolph Herbert, one of the street people of
Philadelphia.
Herbert is a high school dropout. He spent time in jail as a juvenile and
as an adult. He is the father of two boys born to a woman he never married. He
doesn't know where they are. Maybe in a shelter, he says. He has lived in the
streets off and on for six years. He has used drugs. His job, if it could be
called that, is scavenging trash.
All this and he is only 27.
"I could steal, take money, stuff like that - but I was raised
better than that," Herbert says, then corrects himself. "I have done
it, see, but I haven't done it lately. I might get high now and then. But I'm
out there hustling, getting copper and iron. "
This is just one man, one case. There are many others. These young blacks
have become the Nowhere Men: not at home, not at school, not working, not
getting married, not raising families. Going nowhere fast.
Most of these young men in trouble come from the poorest of the poor black
neighborhoods. Data usually are not kept on the income level of prisoners,
parolees, probationers and homicide victims. But the evidence there is, and the
overwhelming testimony of those who work with these men, indicate that the
problems are most heavily concentrated among the city's estimated 40,000 young
black men who live below or near the poverty line - not the 60,000 or so 15- to
34-year-old black males who are not poor.
The problems of these poor, young men disturbs those who have worked with
black youth for decades, among them Sister Falaka Fattah, founder of House of
Umoja in West Philadelphia.
"I think we are in a storm with this generation," she said.
"It is worse than it was. "
How to measure the intensity of that storm? One way is to look at the
number of 15- to 34-year-old black males from Philadelphia who are on probation
or parole, in juvenile detention or in state prisons.
One in five.
There were 12,955 on probation, parole or both last July. In December
3,560 were serving time in state prisons. In January, 3,829 youths aged 15 to
19 were in juvenile jails or on probation.
The total, 20,344, is 20 percent of the black men in Philadelphia between
ages 15 and 34.
Statistics from criminal justice agencies were not available for the same
month, although officials say the numbers do not vary much from month to month.
At the same time, one out of 28 white males in the same age range in
Philadelphia was under supervision of the criminal justice system. According to
the latest estimates, there are 158,000 white men aged 15 to 34 in the city.
Again, these statistics measure age and race but not economic class.
"What's wrong with the statistics," says James Zellars, 27,
"is that everybody gets lumped together. I see role models, I see people looking
inside themselves and wanting to be better. Despite what people say, I see this
from a grass-roots level. "
Zellars, who grew up in North Philadelphia and still lives there, works
for the IRS. He is like the majority of black men - certainly, of middle-class
men - who are not part of these numbers. They have never been arrested or spent
time in jail. They are fathers, workers, husbands, students.
But an effect of all these problems - as
the parents of young black men often testify - is that the behavior and actions
of the most troubled shape public perception of the whole group, as people rush
to make generalizations. This, in turn, helps define what young black men think
of themselves.
"Part of what confronts black males is the perception of the larger
society that they are criminals," explains Fred Shack, who has worked with
troubled youths as a counselor and executive at Southern Home Services in South
Philadelphia.
"A lot of young people buy that image. They don't have the ego
strength to shut that off and say: 'That's not me. '
"When people cross to the other side of the street just because they
see you coming, and that's constant, it's everyday - it's very subtle, but it
makes a difference. When you have that and you don't have a lot of support
systems and a lot of positive role models, you begin to say:
" 'They're the adults, they're the larger society; it must be true.
That must be what I'm about, what I should be doing. So why try to prove the
whole world wrong? I'm just a 14-year-old kid. You're telling me I look like a
crook, I look like a thief, I'm someone to be feared. ' "
Those who work with poor, young black men insist that something must be
done, their problems somehow addressed, if poor communities are to be made
whole. The absence of young black men means more than simply an economic loss.
They point to just one aspect, the impact of so many missing fathers.
"I look at how poor, black males get caught, and they get caught at
a very early age - very early," says George Davis, director of a program
for drug addicts at Gaudenzia House in West Chester. "I'm talking
preschool, elementary school. They get caught with no role models, no identity,
no traditions, no family unit, no belonging.
"When you look at that piece that is supposed to be gotten in the
home, if you don't have the father figure there - that leader, that role model,
that person who is going to guide the family - you have lost something.
Something that child is supposed to have.
"So, the child grows up with the values he learns in the street. And
for the most part, those values are anti-system. They are: 'Only the strong
survive. ' They are: 'You need to do whatever you need to do to make it. '
"
Or, listen to Asa Anderson, 27, one of five children, who grew up fatherless
and poor and is now a recovering drug addict.
"When there's no man around, you automatically go out searching for
some type of manly figure," says Anderson. "But what you usually see
on the streets of Philadelphia are drug dealers, numbers writers, somebody
getting something illegal. "
Most blacks have an acute awareness of the seriousness of the problems of
poor, young men.
Some look at drugs, crime, infant mortality and dropout rates, the
soaring prison populations and the newest scourge, AIDS, and attribute them to
a single source, called "The Conspiracy" or "The Plan. "
In its most extreme version, it is a theory that there is a plot to
exterminate blacks, a plot devised by white leaders and directed from the sub-
basement of the White House.
There are other places to search for answers, though, places closer to
home - in the streets and the shelters, among those who tend to poor, young
blacks. Among the men themselves.
It can begin in a cell at Graterford
Prison, where Kevin Mines sits, a lean and tall, angular, black man, dressed in
the light brown slacks and shirt of an inmate.
Mines has had a lot of time to think about how he got into trouble. He is
four years into a life sentence for murder conspiracy.
He is 28, grew up in North Philadelphia, held a number of good
construction jobs, had a mother and father who warned him of the dangers of
drugs and running with the wrong crowd. To no avail. Mines took to both.
"I went as far as the 10th grade," he recalls. "I didn't
like school
because my peer group wasn't in school. That's the thing that holds a lot
back - they want to be with the fellows. The guys I considered to be role
models, the ones I was influenced by . . . I thought selling drugs, hanging out
was right. "
Mines was robbing a man one night in 1983 outside a Germantown club when
the victim shot him in the stomach. The man was then shot and killed by Mines'
accomplice, who is serving a life sentence, too.
Mines has converted to Islam in prison and, if he had the chance, would tell
every 16-year-old "to realize the existence of God" and avoid the
temptations to which he succumbed.
As he stresses, that is easier said than done.
"I grew up around 15th and Venango," he says. "It's worse
now than it used to be. There's no respect in the community anymore. We used to
not sell drugs on the corners if we knew someone's parents were looking. It's
not like that now. The community is ravaged. Families have fallen apart. "
There are psychologists and drug counselors, professors and politicians
who say much the same thing. Mines' statement is merely more succinct.
Racial discrimination and the lack of jobs have long been seen at the
root of the ghetto's most serious problems.
But those causes have been joined by others: Widespread use of drugs,
particularly cheap and potent crack, is the most recent. The steep climb in the
number of unmarried mothers is another. High dropout rates among the poorest of
black males; the persistence and increased violence of crime. This list could
go on.
Those who work to help the poor say they sometimes feel the bottom has
fallen out of the bottom. Some talk nostalgically of the late 1960s and early
1970s, when the biggest worry was gangs.
"I was working in the gang era, and gang members were 100 percent more
respectful than these youngsters," says Herman Wrice, now active in
anti-drug efforts in the city's Mantua section. "Gangs would only fight
once a week, over turf. The rest of the time they were playing, and most could
read and write. "
"When we were dealing with gangs, there was a certain kind of
tradition," adds Fattah. "I don't like to use the word subculture,
but Philadelphia is one of the cities that put the 'G' in gangdom. So, there's
certain traditions that were adhered to strictly. Nowadays you can't find it.
"
As Mines put it, the ghetto was not a garden spot when he was growing up,
''but it was better than it is now. This is getting ugly. "
Look at the changes that have occurred in his lifetime.
In 1961, the year Mines was born, three out of four black women in
Philadelphia who gave birth were married. Since then, that figure has been
turned on its head: now three out of four are single.
By the time Mines was ready for kindergarten, an exodus was under way
from his and other older black neighborhoods. The area around 15th and Venango
Streets lost 37 percent of its population between 1960 and 1980.
To the south, lower North Philadelphia lost 28 percent of its population
during the 1970s alone.
A lot of those who left were members of the black middle class. Hemmed in
the ghetto for so many years by housing discrimination, they were freed to look
elsewhere in the mid-1960s by federal open housing laws.
In Mines' neighborhood, while the population was dropping, the number of
people living in poverty doubled between 1970 and 1980. In the city, the number
of underclass census tracts - those where 40 percent or more residents are poor
- tripled in the same decade.
Black neighborhoods, once segregated by race alone, became segregated by
race and class.
Families and neighborhoods, the walls that hold many troubles at bay,
were crumbling - sometimes literally so.
As the ghetto emptied, the housing stock deteriorated. In some of the
city's poorest neighborhoods, as many as four out of 10 houses are abandoned or
have been torn down. Children play in the rubble.
Those who help and study the poor, measuring the change over just the
last 25 years, are increasingly dismayed.
"When you talk to kids who make it, they say they were involved with
somebody who inspired them," explains Robert Sorrell, president of the
Philadelphia Urban League. "Now in the neighborhoods, while there is still
some of that going on, it is hidden. People are more transient, more isolated.
Communities are not as close as they once were for a lot of reasons. "
Inez Bruce, a counselor and director at Southern Home Services, remembers
when "black people thrived on neighbors who said: 'I'm going to tell your
momma when she comes home. ' Now, I've got grandmothers and mothers and daughters
who are all using crack. "
Elijah Anderson is a University of Pennsylvania sociologist who has
studied why poor, young, black men father children by women they do not intend
to marry or support. He believes most of the ills in the black community can be
ascribed to economic causes, but adds:
"I think there is a problem even without the economy. . . . There
are no significant sanctions against this kind of behavior. It may be we'll be
able to relate this to the exodus of the black middle class and the black
working class. All of this undermined sanctions against this behavior. "
It would be incorrect to ascribe these ills exclusively to poor blacks.
For instance, while the black rate for out-of-wedlock births tripled from
1960 to 1988, the rate increased more than 10 times among white women in
Philadelphia. The white out-of-wedlock rate is still much lower than the rate
for blacks: 31 percent compared with 75 percent.
The evidence, the statistics, the testimony of experts point to the fact
that problems such as the out-of-wedlock rate are worst in black neighborhoods,
exacerbated by poverty.
Take just one example: the absence of eligible men.
Women everywhere complain how hard it is to find men to marry. Social
scientists have actually developed an index that provides a crude measure of
the pool of marriageable men - they define "marriageable" as any
single man, aged 25 to 44, who is employed.
Using 1980 census data, Paul A. Jargowsky of Harvard University recently
developed a marriageability index for neighborhoods in a number of communities,
including the Philadelphia area.
Among whites in the area's better-off neighborhoods, the rate was 85.
That means there were 85 "marriageable" men for every 100 women. In
the poorest white neighborhoods, the index dipped: The rate was 64.
In middle-class black neighborhoods, the rate was 66.
In the poorest black neighborhoods there were only 33 eligible men for
every 100 women.
This data is 10 years old. Once data from the 1990 census becomes
available, it may show that the marriageability rate has improved because more
black men are working today than in 1980.
Ten years ago, 22 percent of all black men over the age of 19 in
Philadelphia were unemployed, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
That unemployment rate was down to 10 percent as of 1988, the last full year
for which figures are available.
This is good news, but the numbers fail to take into account several
factors: They do not include so-called discouraged workers, people who have
been out of work for so long, they have quit looking for jobs. They also do not
reveal the kinds of jobs and salaries available for unskilled men.
The city's economy has changed drastically in a short time.
When Kevin Mines was born, nearly 40 percent of all the jobs in the city
were in manufacturing. By last year, it was down to 12 percent.
Not that black men in the 1960s all worked on the assembly line. There
was a long history of excluding blacks from prime manufacturing jobs. A lot of
them were relegated to the kind of work the father of Inez Bruce did.
"My mother was a domestic and my dad worked at Allied Chemicals for
most of his life," Bruce recalls. "He was a house builder - he built
our house - but he couldn't do that at Allied Chemicals. He had to sweep the
floors. "
During the 1960s, those barriers began to break down - at exactly the
time the manufacturing jobs were leaving town, as plants shut down, went south
or overseas.
"Black men got piped aboard a sinking ship," said Roger Lane, a
Haverford
College social scientist who has studied the city's black community.
"They finally got the job opportunities when the job opportunities were
leaving.
"Now, we've got this new post-industrial service economy, with its
enormous premium on education. The growth in terms of jobs is for people with
better than high school educations.
"The black male population wants the jobs their grandfathers weren't
allowed to have: 'Give us the macho jobs,' they say. Those jobs are not there.
"
Macho jobs.
Young black men used the same phrase in describing to David W. Lacey the
work they wanted. Until he left for a new job recently, Lacey was president of
the Private Industry Council, which recruits and trains young, poor people for
jobs. He says there are jobs that go begging, but they are in the service
sector.
"I've got to tell them, in this labor market, at this time, fewer
than two in 10 jobs could be defined as 'macho,' " explains Lacey.
"The problem with service jobs, among minority males, is that they say
it's women's work. "
The result is that a lot of young, black men have yet to find their niche
in the new economy.
Anderson, the Penn professor, said this, in turn, led to "economic
dislocation" - which is another way of saying people find themselves
without jobs, living in poverty, with limited prospects for employment.
"The change from manufacturing to service is really quite
profound," he said. "We are still trying to deal with it. But I would
submit that those changes have really helped to undermine the stability of poor
communities, and the black community in particular. "
The change has had a profound effect on society as a whole. But its most
drastic impact has been on poor, black men.
"Anybody who prepares themselves should be able to lead ordinary, if
not extraordinary lives, but we can no longer say go to school, get a job,
raise a family and retire on Social Security," said Thad Mathis of
Temple's Graduate School of Social Administration.
As an issue, the fate of young, black men isn't "sexy enough to
command attention," Mathis says. "Prospects are looking
gloomier," he adds. ''Even kids in school are losing ground. "
There is more to it than plain and simple economics. Lacey said poor,
young black men come to the Private Industry Council with more baggage than
simply a disdain for service jobs. He talked about three hurdles they have to
clear:
"The first is that there is, in many instances, no (recent) family
history of working. So, it is a real act of courage for a young black man to
say, 'I want to split with the past, get myself trained and prepared, so I can
go to work. '
"The second hurdle they face is derision from their peers, who say:
'Oh, fine, you go into a training program, you end up working at McDonald's.'
Or, who say: 'You get your GED, you know what's going to happen to you? You're
going to end up working at McDonald's.'
"The third thing young minority males have to overcome is what I
would call the pain of being poor.
"What I mean is, many of these young men live where the housing is
not particularly favorable, where there's lots of crime, where there's lots
of drug stuff. There can be robberies. There can be beatings. So, you are
living in an environment that is a painful one. It takes time, it takes courage
to make a break from that. "
That kind of courage is hard to come by in poor neighborhoods, where
temptation sits just outside the door. Or parked at the curb, like the sleek
Cadillac owned by a friend of Mesoin Williams'.
The friend cannot understand why Williams won't sell drugs. Look at what
you can get, he tells his friend: a car like mine, lots of money, hand-
tailored clothes. Why wait for the good life, Mesoin? Get it now.
Time was when Williams, who is 22, would have listened to those whispers.
He was, he says, a "ruffian" as a teenager, the kind of guy who
started fights.
He came from a broken home in West Philadelphia, was thrown out of two
high schools, was far along the path to trouble when he stopped for a minute to
think.
" 'Hey, is this who you are? Is this what you want?' " he
recalls asking himself. "I realized I wasn't a dumb guy. I had never
really thought about it because I was too busy doing other things. But,
when I decided to become serious about it, I found out I wasn't that dumb. I
was sort of bright. Bright enough to enroll in junior college
- he is a student at Community College of Philadelphia. Bright enough to
go to the Wharton School, where he will start taking courses this fall. He also
wants to go to law school someday. Being on this new path makes it tough to be
with old friends.
"As I became more serious about school, just day-to-day relations
became awkward," he says. "My aspirations were to do well in school,
to pick up a book, maybe speak better, to stop using slang.
"When you start to do that, it's sort of like people say, 'You're
trying to disassociate yourself,' when actually you're not. You're just trying
to better yourself. But, of course, it's not viewed that way. "
Williams is optimistic about the future. He has set aside immediate
reward.
Fred Shack worries these are attributes many poor, young black men lack.
Shack has worked for years with juveniles here and in New York and
remembers once asking a 17-year-old where he planned to be in five years.
"And this kid, with the straightest face, with absolutely no
remorse, said to me: 'I'm going to be in prison. '
"He didn't have a criminal record, was not into a lot of street
crime. I said, 'Why is that your vision? Why is that the outcome? ' And he said
most of his brothers, cousins and uncles had gone to jail.
"He had completed the eighth grade but was basically nonfunctional
in school. He had no real vocational skills. He realized that in another year
he was not going to be able to stay in the child welfare system. And he just
knew that would be his fate. "
Shack has not seen the young man in years. He bets he did end up in jail.
Pessimism and impatience. Those who deal with young, poor black men often
stress such intangibles. People like Shack worry as much about these young
men's lack of values as their lack of education, the absence of positive role
models as much as the absence of the right kind of jobs.
For instance, Davis, the director at Gaudenzia House in West Chester,
worries about the pervasive effects of a ghetto environment.
"In looking at black males, you are talking about individuals who,
more often than not, have a criminal history, limited employment skills, and
when they leave one institution, they go right back into the environment they
came from. They can't find a job. They get caught up in the environment. . . .
And the one thing that hasn't stopped is that they are still making babies.
"These babies are growing up and they don't have any leadership.
They don't have any role models. They don't have a culture - to learn, or to
relate to. And what happens is, they get caught up in that cycle. They have
nowhere to go. They have nothing to do. They see no out. "
Elijah Anderson also is concerned about poor, young men who make babies.
They do it, he says, not with the intent of marrying the girl or supporting the
child, but because it makes them bigger men among their friends.
"The problem is that within the
lower classes, there is this profound ignorance of one's body, of birth control
and all that," Anderson says. ''There is profound sexism - in that a woman
is responsible to protect herself. It is not seen as a male responsibility.
Yet, the male requires sex. Yet, sex results in babies. Yet, a lot of the boys
are not interested in 'playing house. '
"The boys who impregnate the girls often are older. Sometimes the
fact that there is an older man of 21 is very attractive to a girl 15 or 16.
So, he has a certain advantage in playing the game. His behavior results in
babies and it reflects on him in a positive way. "
Herman Wrice expresses the same concern in a different way.
"In neighborhoods where there is much promiscuity, we're working
with kids 9 to 12 trying to cut down on the number of unwanted
pregnancies," he says. ''We're shooting for the second level of kids, 12,
13, 14.
"Most over 21 are not too open. They got caught up in the fantasy
game of gold, fast track, no respect for country, elders, just leaving kids any
place they can. Like it's a badge of honor. "
Gold and drugs. The fast track. For many poor, young, black men that
track ends inside the prison gate. Donald Vaughn sees them arrive.
Like many of them, Vaughn, 47, grew up on the streets of North
Philadelphia. Unlike them, as he put it, "I worked my way through without
going to jail. "
Vaughn said he walked through gang territory all the time but never
became a member.
"My father always made me wear a white shirt and a tie," he
recalled. ''Most of my friends, the mothers or - in most cases, their
grandmothers - were raising them. I'd be teased. I didn't realize then that I
was better off than many of them were. They'd be staying out late, down on the
corner, but not me. My parents had to know where I was. "
Vaughn met some of those guys in prison later. They were inmates, he a
guard.
Today, he is superintendent.
Now, he sees their sons come in.
"Father's already here, and the son comes," he says. "I
have one case where a mother, she only has two sons and both are here doing
life. She asked me one day, 'What did I do wrong? ' She had been trying to
raise them herself. What can you say? It's depressing sometimes."
From the Philadelphia Inquirer